Choose Etsy if you need people who don’t know your work yet to find it: marketplace search is what its higher per-order fees pay for. Choose Big Cartel if you already have an audience to send to a small store of your own and want to keep more of each sale. Plenty of makers use both, and that works if you decide upfront how the two channels share stock.
Setka is our product. Like Big Cartel, it gives you a store of your own, which Setka builds around your products, and like Big Cartel, it needs you to bring the visitors. It doesn’t replace Etsy’s marketplace.
Five designs, fifty prints
Take a fictional illustrator releasing five original designs in one fixed format, ten copies of each. That’s five products and fifty units. Platform limits count products, not the units on the shelf.
Big Cartel’s Gold plan, checked on 28 September 2026, allows five products, so this release fits the free plan. Platinum allows 50 products and Diamond 500, according to its plan documentation. Extra capacity is no reason to upgrade a five-design release; only features the release needs are. Our Big Cartel pricing guide works through each plan and its payment fees.
Gold also allows one image per product, and for prints that is the real limit. A buyer may want to see the artwork, the paper surface, and how the print arrives. Paid plans allow more images. Decide from what buyers need to see, not from whether the free plan feels like enough.
Etsy adds a question Big Cartel doesn’t ask: does the product qualify? Its Creativity Standards cover items the seller made, designed, handpicked, or sourced, with rules for each category. The version captured on 15 August 2026 covers original designs and when to disclose a production partner. Check the way your prints are actually produced against those rules before you plan on Etsy; a small catalog doesn’t make a listing eligible.
Where will the first twenty buyers come from?
The answer splits the recommendation in two.
An audience is already waiting. Newsletter readers and social followers know the illustrator’s work. A compact Big Cartel store gives them somewhere to buy: choose a template, add the five products, set up payments and delivery, and test the purchase path.
The illustrator needs people who don’t know the work yet. Etsy’s marketplace search and browsing are a possible route to them. The listing has to explain the print, meet Etsy’s rules, and stand out among other results. Etsy’s Seller Policy, checked on 5 October 2026, describes factors that affect visibility; a listing guarantees neither visitors nor sales.
Strangers can buy from a store of your own too. What’s missing is how they get there. “We’ll put the link in our bio” names a destination; it still needs a reason for the right people to visit the bio.
What the product page has to show
Big Cartel’s customization guide describes templates, visual settings, custom pages on paid plans, and a code section for deeper changes. Anything the settings can’t do becomes custom code work.
Before choosing a template for the print release, write down three requirements:
- Visitors can see all five designs together and can tell a sold-out print from an available one.
- The product page makes the fixed dimensions, the paper, and the fact that no frame is included clear.
- The images show what the print looks like and how it arrives.
Then read the page as two different buyers. A collector who knows the artist looks for edition details, printing method, and paper. Someone buying a housewarming gift wants to know how big it looks on a wall, whether a frame is included, and whether it will arrive in time.
On Etsy, you fill in Etsy’s listing page. On Big Cartel, you configure a template to present the release. Either way, check that the photos match the print, the dimensions agree everywhere, and delivery and returns information is easy to find before checkout. If other retail requirements come into the decision, read our Big Cartel and Shopify comparison.
What each channel costs per order
Big Cartel’s processing-fees guide, checked on 28 September 2026, says Big Cartel charges no platform transaction fee. Stripe or PayPal processing is separate. The five products fit Gold, though the images or tools the release needs may put it on a paid plan.
Etsy’s fees policy, checked on 5 October 2026, lists a $0.20 USD listing fee and a 6.5% transaction fee on the displayed price plus seller-charged shipping and gift wrap. For US sellers, the transaction fee excludes sales tax; outside the US, the listing price includes the taxes the seller is responsible for. Each additional unit sold from a listing, and each renewal, adds another listing fee. Payment processing applies to the order total including shipping and tax, at a rate set by the seller’s bank country. Attributed Offsite Ads and country-specific charges can add to the total, and a one-time, non-refundable shop setup fee may apply, with the location-dependent amount shown during onboarding.
Here is one hypothetical order for a US seller: a $40 print with $6 shipping, no sales tax, paid by card, and not attributed to Offsite Ads.
- Etsy: $2.99 transaction fee (6.5% of $46), $1.63 processing (3% plus $0.25 under Etsy’s US payments rate, checked on 5 October 2026), and $0.20 when the listing renews after the sale. Total: $4.82.
- Big Cartel with Stripe: $1.63 processing (2.9% plus $0.30, the US card example in Big Cartel’s guide) and no platform fee. Total: $1.63, plus the subscription if the release needs a paid plan.
That’s about $3.20 more per order on Etsy, or over $150 if all fifty prints sell as single orders. The store of your own keeps that money only when you bring the buyers. For an artist with an audience already waiting, it does. For one who needs strangers to find the work, Etsy’s fees are the price of that discovery, and an order Etsy would have found for you doesn’t belong in your own store’s forecast unless you have another way to win it.
If both channels sell the same stock
The fifty prints exist once. If each channel shows ten copies of every design, together they can promise more than the illustrator owns unless something keeps the quantities aligned.
A simple start is six copies of each design for your own store and four for Etsy. Decide when unsold copies move between channels, who changes the quantities, and how a refund affects availability. If you use a connector, test exactly how it updates stock, including two orders arriving at once, before you rely on it.
The channels also keep separate messages, order records, and policies. Etsy’s off-platform rule, checked on 5 October 2026, prohibits moving an Etsy-initiated transaction elsewhere, and its buyer-data rules restrict using buyers’ details for marketing without consent. Marketing your own store separately is fine; diverting a marketplace sale isn’t.
Etsy’s Pattern is another option: a branded site whose inventory you manage in Etsy Shop Manager. Its documented price, checked on 5 October 2026, is $15 USD per month after a 30-day trial, plus applicable tax, and Etsy says Pattern sites don’t appear in marketplace search. If keeping one set of stock records matters most, look at Pattern before adding a separate platform.
When your own store has to do more than a template
If the illustrator likes a Big Cartel template and can bring buyers to the release, Big Cartel is a sound choice. If the plan depends on marketplace discovery for work that qualifies, start on Etsy.
Choose Setka when your own store is where the collection should be presented properly and changed with each release. An Etsy listing uses Etsy’s page; a template uses a layout designed for every shop on the platform. In Setka you write a brief instead: “Show the five designs as one series, explain the print dimensions before purchase, and use the artist’s story to connect the collection.” Setka builds the store from that brief and your catalog, inside the platform that also runs checkout and orders. For the next release, you describe the change or edit the exact wording, preview it, and publish, with no theme code to maintain. Setka’s price doesn’t rise with your sales; Stripe’s processing fees apply.
Sizes and frames work as product variants, each combination with its own price. Personalized prints aren’t available yet. If you need them, or plan to share stock between Setka and an Etsy shop, write to contact@getsetka.com before you move: requests go straight to the people building Setka. You still supply the artwork, the facts, prices, shipping rules, the audience, and fulfillment.
If presenting the collection your way is why you want your own store, start it in Setka and check the generated pages against the three requirements above.