Choose Big Cartel when buyers arrive ready to browse a small range and one of its templates already presents that range well. Choose Squarespace when a portfolio, journal, or buying guide helps people decide what to buy, and you are happy to build and keep up that website yourself. What separates them is how much explaining has to happen before someone reaches a product.
Setka is our product, and it offers a third route. You bring the products and the story buyers need; Setka builds the whole store from that brief and catalog, and you direct later changes by describing them. We cover where it fits after the two platforms.
Start with the route to a purchase
An illustrator selling six print designs might need little more than clear photographs, paper and size details, framing information, and a reliable dispatch promise. Someone following a link to a print they already love should find the print and its buying information immediately. A focused shop serves that customer well.
A gift buyer may arrive with a different question: which print suits a small apartment, and does it need a frame? A page comparing sizes or showing work in a room earns its place in the store, as long as it leads to the relevant products instead of sending the visitor back to the catalog to start again.
That is the case for a fuller website: extra pages are worth having when they remove a doubt. A long artist biography, an unrelated journal, and elaborate navigation can just as easily make six products harder to buy.
| Your store needs | Stronger starting choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A compact range with direct product browsing | Big Cartel | Its catalog and template workflow keep the shop focused. |
| A portfolio or regular editorial content connected to products | Squarespace | Pages and posts can carry catalog-backed product blocks. |
| A tailored shop you can direct without maintaining theme code | Setka | The platform builds and changes the store around your brief and catalog. |
Big Cartel: let the catalog carry the shop
Big Cartel’s free Gold plan holds five products, Platinum 50, and Diamond 500, with one, five, and 25 images per product respectively, according to its plans and features as of 16 October 2026. The image allowance decides the plan as often as the product count. Six prints with three photographs each need Platinum, and even a five-product range needs a paid plan once one photograph isn’t enough. Our Big Cartel review covers what the store does beyond these allowances.
The store starts from a template. You set its colors, fonts, imagery, and whatever layout options it offers, and paid plans add custom pages, so a focused shop can still explain the maker, framing, care, or shipping. Big Cartel’s template documentation notes that templates differ in homepage structure, navigation, and product presentation. Choose one for how it organizes your actual products as well as for how it looks.
That is enough when most changes mean adding products, replacing photographs, updating descriptions, and adjusting the available settings. A distinctive body of work doesn’t by itself call for a custom website.
The limit shows when you want a layout or buying route the template doesn’t provide. Big Cartel allows deeper code changes, but someone has to make them and keep them working, and its documentation warns that custom code and settings may behave differently after a template switch. The subscription stays low; the custom presentation becomes a separate job.
Big Cartel also has an app catalog and documented SEO settings, so marketing and search basics won’t decide this choice. Content and composition will.
Squarespace: make supporting content lead somewhere
Squarespace’s concrete advantage for a content-led shop is the product block. It shows a product from your store inside another page or post, including a blog post, and when you update the product in the catalog, every block showing it updates too. Each block shows one product, and the store page must be enabled with the product published and visible, as Squarespace’s product block guide explains. Our Squarespace e-commerce review covers when content and commerce belong together.
For the print shop, a framing guide could explain the sizes and then show the right print for purchase. A portfolio page could describe a series with the matching product beside the work. Where a block would interrupt the page, a plain product link does the job.
The catalog connection matters. Type a price into three paragraphs and you have three places to correct it later; a block keeps the displayed details tied to the product. The words around the block still need an owner, though. A line promising dispatch next week doesn’t become true because the price beside it is current.
Squarespace also builds with AI. Its documentation describes Blueprint AI generating a site from business and brand inputs, which you then review and refine in the editor, plus AI writing tools for areas such as product descriptions and blog posts. What you get is a starting point in the same editor, and the composing and upkeep stay with you.
Choose Squarespace if that is work you want to own. A useful journal has an ongoing editorial cost, even when a tool drafts the text.
Compare costs against the store you need
Big Cartel is cheaper to start: Gold is free, and the paid plans displayed on 16 October 2026 cost $15 and $30 a month. Big Cartel charges a 0% transaction fee; Stripe or PayPal processing is billed separately. Our Big Cartel pricing explanation works through the annual outlay and per-order arithmetic.
Squarespace’s Basic, Core, Plus, and Advanced plans treat physical-product sales separately from digital content. For physical products, Basic adds a 2% platform commerce fee and the higher plans add none; processing is extra. On the US offer displayed on 16 October 2026, Basic costs $19 and Core $29 a month billed annually, so under the fee guide Core becomes the cheaper plan once physical sales pass $500 a month. The fees Squarespace charges on courses and memberships don’t apply to a physical print. Our Squarespace pricing guide works through the arithmetic.
Pay for Squarespace when its website tools do real selling work, and pay less for Big Cartel when a template already does the job. Neither subscription covers the maker’s time spent choosing images, checking product facts, and deciding what to say.
Moving products does not move the whole website
If you already use Squarespace, Big Cartel documents a product import route. Imported products start hidden, and the destination plan’s product and image limits apply. Keep the old store online while importing so its images stay accessible.
Treat that as a catalog transfer. It doesn’t move your portfolio design, journal, customer records, order history, or old URLs. An established body of useful content is part of the switching decision: keep it if it still serves customers, and plan for rebuilding its paths if you leave.
If you move to Setka instead, we migrate your existing store data for you; tell us what you have, including journal posts. Redirects from old URLs are not available yet. If your current URLs carry search traffic you can’t lose, tell us at contact@getsetka.com: requests go straight to the people building Setka.
Choose Setka when you want to direct the whole shop
Big Cartel limits the presentation to what its template offers unless someone writes code. Squarespace hands you the pieces and leaves the composing to you. Setka builds the homepage, collection pages, product page templates, navigation, and cart from your brief and catalog, using your product data and images. One brief shapes every page, so the gift buyer’s guidance and the collector’s paper and size details belong to the same store. You decide what each customer needs to understand.
After launch, you keep directing it. Open a page, describe what should change and where, and preview the next version before publishing. When you know the exact wording, edit it directly. Every change creates a storefront version you can branch from or return to. Setka also includes a built-in blog and CMS; embedding catalog products in a post, the job Squarespace’s product block does, is coming soon.
We recommend Setka when you know the brand and product story you want to tell, and assembling or coding the presentation is what stands in the way. That doesn’t mean building a complicated website: a clear six-product shop can be the right result.
Choose Big Cartel if its template already does the job. Choose Squarespace if you want to compose a broader website around your products. If you want a store built around your range that you can keep directing, start with Setka. Bring the products, the facts buyers need, and the direction you want the store to take.