Use Replit, Base44, or Bolt when a custom buying flow or business application is worth owning, along with everything it takes to keep it running. If you’re a physical-product brand that mainly needs to show a catalog, take orders, and keep improving the store, choose a commerce platform instead.
All three can build real commerce: catalogs, Stripe checkout, inventory, refunds. The difference is what you end up with. An app builder gives you a generated application that you shape, deploy, and look after. A commerce platform gives you a store whose order, payment, and inventory handling already exists and is maintained for you.
Setka is our product, and it’s built for the second job: a store designed around your brand, with no storefront codebase for you to maintain.
What each builder offers
Replit describes generating a catalog, connecting a database, adding Stripe or PayPal checkout, and extending admin and order flows with its Agent. Its website workflow includes preview, deployment, and checkpoints. That is a credible way to build a commerce application. The elaborate sample prompts on its pages describe what you could ask the Agent to build, not features already set up in every store. Replit’s commerce builder.
Base44 documents a specific Stripe setup. Its guide, checked on 16 October 2026, covers installation from chat on Builder and higher plans, creating products, testing in a sandbox, and switching on live payments. Products and prices in that flow live in Stripe; the guide says it doesn’t automatically create a separate product database. Its examples also cover purchase records, preventing a payment from taking effect twice, and changing access after a refund. Base44’s Stripe documentation.
Base44 also offers Base44 Payments powered by Wix, a separate payment route with its own supported-country and verification requirements, a payments dashboard, and refunds. It is a different product from the Stripe integration. Between the two, Base44 clearly handles payments and refunds. Base44 Payments documentation.
Bolt.new markets custom e-commerce stores with databases, dynamic inventory, and Stripe payments, and its help center documents Stripe for one-time payments and subscriptions. It’s selling application behavior, not just visual design. Bolt’s e-commerce use case and Stripe integration guide.
None of these pages can tell you how your own stock, orders, shipping, and refunds will behave. That depends on what gets built for your store, and an attractive demo doesn’t show it.
Follow one product past checkout
Take a hypothetical tea brand selling 12 products. One is a caffeine-free herbal tin. The brand wants real photographs, ingredients, weight, brewing instructions, stock levels, and a clear dispatch promise.
In a generated app, that tin needs one authoritative product record. A Stripe price tells checkout what to charge; the application still has to know what the customer bought, which stock to reduce, and what to show on the order.
The sequence that matters is ordinary:
- A customer selects the tin and a delivery option.
- A successful payment becomes a paid order, exactly once.
- The right stock count drops and confirmations go out.
- The merchant finds the order and ships it.
- A partial refund weeks later stays attached to the right purchase.
AI can implement every one of these steps, and you don’t have to write the functions by hand. Someone still owns how the application behaves, which version is deployed, and the fix when a requirement changes. That may be you, a developer, or a contracted team. Hosting included in the builder doesn’t make that question go away.
The second change shows what you bought
Now the tea brand wants to feature caffeine-free gifts. This is a merchandising change: explain who the collection suits, bring the right tins forward, and keep ingredients and weights accurate.
An app builder can produce a tailored interface for it. That flexibility pays off when the change also needs a distinctive workflow in the application. If all you want is a better collection page, owning custom commerce logic buys more responsibility than the brand needs.
Either way, the merchant stays responsible for the product facts and commercial decisions. The platform choice decides who turns that direction into a working store, and who keeps the presentation compatible with the commerce behind it.
Then the dispatch promise changes from two days to three. That’s a different job: an exact correction to one sentence, wherever it appears. Regenerating a whole design to change a sentence is the wrong tool. Whatever you pick, check that it lets you make a precise text edit without touching anything else.
When a custom app earns its place
Choose an app builder when the application is part of what you’re selling. Maybe buyers need a bespoke workflow tied to your internal data, or the purchase is one step in a broader service. Then the freedom to shape data, screens, and logic can be worth the ongoing implementation work.
You can also put a separate commerce engine behind a custom application. That can be a sensible architecture, but its capabilities come from the specific engine and connection you choose. “Any builder can connect to anything” is not an operating plan.
Budget for the app, its services, payment processing, implementation, and every future change. A low builder subscription doesn’t price the whole system. And code access isn’t a flaw: it’s useful control when someone intends to use it.
When Setka is the better choice
For the tea brand, whose needs are an owned store and ordinary physical-product sales, we’d choose Setka. You bring the catalog and the brand direction. Setka builds the homepage, category pages, product-page templates, navigation, and cart inside its own e-commerce platform.
The two later changes look like this. For the caffeine-free gifts, add those tins to a new category (a product can sit in several), open the page, describe who the collection is for and what to emphasize, check the preview, and publish. For the dispatch promise, edit the sentence directly. Every change creates a new version of the whole store, so you can branch from an earlier version and go back to it if needed. You never receive generated theme code to maintain.
The commerce is already there. Connect your own Stripe account, choose one store currency, and set up shipping and taxes. A successful payment creates a paid order, updates inventory, and sends confirmations to the customer and a notification to you. Full and partial refunds are issued from the order. How Setka checkout and Stripe payments work.
The budget changes shape too. Instead of builder usage, separate services, and developer time for each change, you pay one platform subscription plus Stripe’s processing fees. See current pricing.
Each Setka store uses one currency today, and customer accounts aren’t available yet. If either is central to your business, that changes the recommendation. Tell us the requirement at contact@getsetka.com and we’ll answer yes, no, or not yet. Requests go straight to the people building Setka.
Decide what you want to own
If the application is part of your product, build it with Replit, Base44, or Bolt, and plan for who maintains it. If the catalog is the business and the store is how people buy it, start a Setka store with one real collection. Give it accurate products and a clear brand brief, then make the next merchandising change yourself. That change, not the launch, is the work your store will keep asking of you.