Choose Squarespace when stories, a portfolio, and the wider website are how customers come to buy, and you want to compose that site yourself in its editor. Choose Shopify when selling across channels and keeping stock in order run the business, and you’re comfortable owning a theme and the apps around it. Both can carry a branded site with a journal and a store; the difference is which recurring work lands on you. If the work you want gone is building and changing the store itself, there’s a third route: Setka, our product, builds the store inside its own e-commerce platform and lets you direct it.

One ceramics catalog, two ways in

Take a fictional ceramics studio selling twelve fixed products: mugs, bowls, and serving plates, each with its own price, stock, dimensions, glaze description, photos, and care instructions. It publishes making stories, releases a small collection each month, and ships from one workshop. (If you sell pottery yourself, our guide to selling pottery online covers channels and how to prepare a collection.) To keep the comparison on the buying journey, assume individual products only: no subscriptions, configurable sets, or wholesale pricing.

Customers reach the studio’s store in two ways:

  • A reader finds an essay about a speckled glaze, discovers the bowl that uses it, checks its size and care instructions, and orders it.
  • A shopper lands on the bowl’s product page from a search for an everyday breakfast bowl, decides whether it suits their table, reads the making story if they want to, and orders it.

Both routes have to work. The essay should make the bowl more desirable without burying the purchase, and the product page should carry enough facts to buy without a detour through the journal. A gift buyer needs to judge suitability and the delivery promise; someone comparing glazes needs the material and finish facts. Neither platform writes those explanations for you. The real question is who builds and maintains both routes, and how comfortably.

Squarespace: the story and the shop in one editor

Squarespace suits a website with several jobs at once: explain the studio, show past work, publish stories, and sell the current collection. You set the site structure around that mix and arrange the pages in the editor.

The starting point now includes AI. Squarespace’s AI guide, checked on 5 October 2026, documents Blueprint AI Builder, Blueprint AI Templates, and Squarespace GPT. Its September product update describes Blueprint AI generating a personalized multi-page site from business and brand inputs, with a whole-site preview and refinement in the editor. AI writing also covers blog posts and product descriptions.

The link between content and commerce is concrete. The product-block guide, checked on 5 October 2026, describes placing one store product in a page or blog post, provided the store page is enabled and the product is published and visible. You choose which details to show, and the product-display guide says edits in the product editor update every block that includes the product.

For the studio, Blueprint AI supplies a starting website and product blocks tie the stories to the catalog. The studio still reviews the structure, supplies accurate product facts, and shapes the result in the editor. Generated prose can’t establish whether a glaze is food-safe or a plate is dishwasher-safe; the maker does.

Squarespace’s advantage here is that the website work the studio wants to do sits in one place. A founder who enjoys arranging an essay, a portfolio, and a collection keeps those tasks together. Before choosing it, confirm that its stock, shipping, discount, and customer-email behavior covers what you sell. A good content workflow doesn’t settle an operational requirement.

Shopify: the website organized around the store

Shopify’s Online Store is a built-in sales channel, not a separate website you buy. Its Online Store documentation, checked on 28 September 2026, puts the full online store on Basic or higher. Shopify has a built-in blogging engine, checked on 5 October 2026, and its writing guide documents immediate and scheduled publishing. A theme-based store and a native journal can share the site; how well they sit together depends on the theme.

Shopify’s pricing comparison, checked on 28 September 2026, lists online and in-person selling, multichannel selling, inventory locations, and commerce reporting, with staff accounts and specialist features varying by plan. Those are the reasons to pick Shopify when the studio’s main recurring problem is coordinating sales and stock across channels. They don’t mean every channel, shipping provider, or staffing setup works on the cheapest plan. Our Shopify pricing guide adds up the plan, theme, apps, and payment fees for a first year.

The studio can tell its story on Shopify too. What it takes on is the theme: choosing one that presents both routes well, then filling gaps. Sort that work into three kinds:

  1. Native: the platform’s products, collections, content, and theme settings.
  2. Added: an app or outside service for a specific requirement.
  3. Custom: someone builds and maintains presentation or behavior beyond the available settings.

A basic blog is native on Shopify, so don’t count it as an app. Equally, a specialist editorial layout isn’t “included” because some app could provide it. For each requirement, write down who supplies it and who fixes it when the theme or the requirement changes. If the studio already runs its sales on Shopify, a content problem may call for a theme adjustment rather than a platform move. If the founder wants to stop managing the theme altogether, another theme leaves the same job in place.

Linking the essay to the bowl

On Squarespace, end the glaze essay with a product block for the bowl, or a direct product link from the link editor. One block shows one product, so an essay about several pieces needs several blocks or a link to the collection.

On Shopify, keep the native journal and an external blog apart. The Buy Button documentation, checked on 5 October 2026, covers embedding products on an external website or blog, with product changes reflected from the Shopify admin. It explicitly advises against Buy Buttons on a Shopify-hosted store or blog because they can cause checkout problems, and points to a cart permalink instead. An external embed isn’t the native journal’s equivalent of a product block.

On either platform, keep price and stock in the product record rather than typing them into the story, and make sure a cart link that skips the product page still tells the reader which bowl they’re buying. Then walk the route on a phone: the reader should recognize the bowl from the essay’s photos, reach it without the menu, see size and care next to the buy button, get the right bowl and quantity in the cart, understand the delivery option and total before paying, and the order should reach whoever packs it. If a styled photo shows three bowls and the listing is for one, say so before the purchase.

The ongoing cost is keeping this route correct. When a price changes, know every place that has to be edited. When the bowl sells out, check what an old essay now sends readers to. Whether the essay keeps pointing at the original bowl or introduces its replacement is an editorial call no platform makes for you.

A class booking needs more than a product

Say the studio later adds a take-home workshop kit and an in-person class. The kit is a physical product: contents, extra tools needed, stock, delivery. The class needs a date, a number of places, and rules for changes and cancellations.

Shopify’s service-product guide, checked on 5 October 2026, separates a non-shippable service product from booking: appointment times and capacity go through an app. Turning off shipping doesn’t create a calendar, so check the app’s charges, support, and cancellation behavior. On Squarespace, product blocks connect content to products but don’t schedule a class; look at its actual service setup before choosing around this requirement. If your current site already handles bookings well, count that as something to keep.

The second collection shows the ongoing work

A month after launch, the studio releases four new pieces. It wants two on the homepage, a new making story, and the earlier essay still useful, with shipping and care information accurate throughout.

On Squarespace, that’s product records plus editor work: add the products, update the content, rearrange the featured section, and walk the purchase route again. On Shopify, it’s product and collection admin plus whatever the theme and blog presentation need, including any app or custom section involved. Then the operational half: lower one product’s stock, change a delivery rule, and have the person who packs orders check the result.

Write down who does each step and where they need help. A founder making the occasional layout change and a founder briefing a designer every month are running different businesses, and both can end up with a good store. The point of the exercise is to see which arrangement you’re buying.

Fees: compare the categories before the plan prices

For physical products, Squarespace’s transaction fee and its payment processing are separate costs. The official fee guide, checked on 5 October 2026, lists a 2% commerce transaction fee on Basic and 0% on Core, Plus, and Advanced for physical, download, and service products and donations. Processing is charged on top. Digital content, courses, videos, and member sites follow a separate schedule of 7%, 5%, 1%, and 0% across the four plans, so a making course needs its own calculation. The same guide says the current plans are rolling out in waves and Plus may not be available in every country, so use the quote your own account shows. Our Squarespace e-commerce pricing guide shows the sales level at which each plan costs less.

If the studio processes $5,000 of physical-product sales in a month on Squarespace Basic, the 2% fee is $100 before processing. A plan with a 0% fee removes that line, not the subscription or the processing.

Shopify’s pricing page, checked on 28 September 2026, separates payment rates from third-party transaction fees; the quote depends on country, provider, plan, and payment method. Add only the apps the store actually needs. For either platform, the real cost is:

Subscription + payment processing + applicable platform transaction fees + required outside tools + the work of building and changing the store.

What to settle before you choose

Fill in each row for both candidates: what meets the condition, which plan or tool it needs, and who owns it. “Possible” isn’t an answer until those are named.

Requirement or assetPass condition for this studioOwner to name
Making stories and portfolioEach story has a home and a clear route to a current or deliberately archived product.Editor who chooses and checks the links
Product facts and mediaAll twelve products keep correct dimensions, care, price, stock, and images.Catalog owner
Monthly collection changeFour new products, homepage features, and a story can go live without unowned design work.Merchant, designer, or developer
Checkout and fulfillmentThe right item and delivery rule reach checkout, and the order reaches the packer.Commerce admin and fulfillment owner
Existing URLs and historyValuable addresses still work; order and customer history stays accessible somewhere agreed.Whoever runs the migration
Commercial dependenciesPayment methods, channels, shipping, and team access work in your market and plan, with add-ons in the total.Business owner

For a fresh launch, the last two rows are requirements; for a move, they’re also things to preserve. Importing a catalog into either platform doesn’t recreate page layouts, theme settings, articles, integrations, or old URLs. Keep the current site running until you know what has to move. The migration checklist covers transfer and cutover, and if your content site already works and you only want to add selling, read embedded commerce versus a full online store first.

When Setka is the better route

Both platforms leave the studio with the same job: someone composes the store, in Squarespace’s editor or through Shopify’s theme and apps, and someone recomposes it every time the collection changes. Setka moves that job onto the platform.

The studio supplies product facts, images, its audience, tone, and direction. Setka builds the homepage, collection pages, product pages, navigation, and cart from that brief and the catalog, inside its own e-commerce platform. For the monthly release, the studio opens a page, describes the change (“feature the two new bowls and lead with the glaze story”), edits exact wording where needed, previews, and publishes. Every change saves a version of the whole store, so the studio can branch from an earlier version or go back to it. There’s no theme to choose or maintain and no app stack to keep compatible.

The commerce runs in the same system. With the studio’s own Stripe account connected, checkout, paid orders, inventory updates, customer confirmations, and full or partial refunds all happen inside Setka. The studio still owns its catalog accuracy, prices, delivery promises, policies, and packing; Setka takes over the storefront, not the business.

For the story-led side, Setka has a built-in blog and CMS. Embedding a catalog product inside a blog post, the way Squarespace’s product block does, is coming soon. If your stories depend on that, on scheduled posts, or on class bookings, tell us at contact@getsetka.com and we’ll answer yes, no, or not yet: requests go straight to the people building Setka.

On cost, for a first store Setka usually costs much less than a Shopify store once the theme, the time spent adapting it, and the apps are counted, because the store is built into the platform. If you already have a store, we migrate its data for you.

Decide with the next collection

Choose Squarespace if arranging the wider website is work you want to keep, the essay-to-bowl route is clear, and its store operations fit your market and plan. Choose Shopify if its selling channels and stock management match how the business runs, and you’re comfortable owning the theme and the additions it needs. Choose Setka if the recurring problem is building and changing the store, and you’d rather direct those changes than make them.

Test any candidate with the next collection: one story-to-product route, one merchandising change, one order. For Setka, see current pricing, then start a Setka store with the same catalog.