For a small business selling its own products, we recommend Setka. You bring the products and brand direction, Setka builds the store around them, and you direct every later change without a theme or an app stack to maintain. Choose Shopify when you sell in person or depend on a specific app or integration, WooCommerce when a WordPress site already earns its keep, Squarespace when you want to write and arrange a content-rich site yourself, and Big Cartel for a deliberately small creative shop.

Setka is our product, and this shortlist is based on each platform’s official documentation, not hands-on testing.

The shortlist at a glance

PlatformStrongest reason to choose itWork you retain
SetkaA store built around your brief and products, with conversational changesProduct truth, merchandising decisions, configuration, and fulfillment
ShopifyHosted commerce with themes, apps, and connected selling routesTheme selection, app decisions, configuration, and deeper customization
WooCommerceWordPress, code control, and a chosen implementationHosting and extension ownership, directly or through a support partner
SquarespaceContent and products in a website you actively editPage composition, editorial upkeep, and commerce configuration
Big CartelA compact, creator-focused shop with explicit catalog capsTemplate configuration and working within the selected plan’s limits

Team size doesn’t decide which of these is right. A one-person business can depend on a warehouse integration, and a larger team can sell a simple catalog. Start with what must work at launch, then choose how you want to run the store after it.

Setka: the store built for you, every change directed by you

Choose Setka when you know your products, customers, and brand direction and don’t want to become a theme designer. You describe the goals, the customer, the tone, colors, and references. Setka turns that brief and your catalog into one direction for the whole store and builds the homepage, collection pages, product-page templates, navigation, and cart from it. Your real descriptions, prices, and photographs fill the pages.

After launch, a small business mostly needs the next change: a new range, a clearer product explanation, a seasonal campaign. In Setka you open the page, describe what should change and where, edit exact wording directly when you know it, preview, and publish. Every change saves a storefront-wide version, so you can branch from an earlier one and return to it. You never get a theme codebase to maintain, because the store and the commerce behind it are one platform.

Checkout runs through your own Stripe account. A paid order updates stock, sends the customer a confirmation, and can be refunded from the order. Setka also includes a blog and CMS. Three answers matter before you choose: each store uses one currency for now, customer accounts aren’t available yet, and there is no POS integration. If your launch needs any of them, tell us at contact@getsetka.com: requests go straight to the people building Setka.

The cost follows the same logic. Setka’s price covers the store as well as the commerce, so there is no theme to buy, no app stack to assemble for the storefront, and no developer to pay for adapting either. The price doesn’t rise with your sales; Stripe’s processing fees apply as they would anywhere. For a product store whose owner wants to keep directing it, Setka is our first recommendation.

Shopify: for in-person selling and the app ecosystem

Shopify is the strong general choice when the business needs hosted commerce plus a wide range of extensions. Its documented offer includes online and in-person selling, so it belongs at the top of the list when a shop counter or market stall shapes the decision. See Shopify’s current platform and plan comparison.

Its Online Store workflow gives you themes and an editor, with a custom-storefront route when standard features don’t meet the requirement. Shopify has its own AI tools, including Sidekick, but they work inside the same theme-and-app model.

Your work is choosing the theme, configuring the store, and deciding which apps or customizations are worth paying for. A good built-in theme can serve a business well. A more specialized presentation or process may add paid software or implementation work. The plan is the start of the bill: a paid theme, the apps that fill gaps, and the developer or evenings spent adapting them belong in the same total, at launch and at every later change.

Choose Shopify when an integration or selling workflow you need makes the theme-and-app model worth it. Our Shopify alternatives guide looks at that decision more closely.

WooCommerce: for a WordPress site worth keeping

WooCommerce makes sense when an existing WordPress site, publishing process, or custom implementation already serves the business. It adds commerce to that site instead of asking you to start over somewhere else.

The core platform is free and open source, with no monthly core subscription or revenue share. Hosting, payment processing, extensions, and implementation are paid separately, so the free license doesn’t make the store free to run.

You choose the host and the support arrangement. A managed host or agency can take on real work, but someone has to own updates, compatibility, backups, and recovery. That is a good trade when control over the implementation is worth something to you.

Choose WooCommerce to keep a site you’ve invested in or to meet a concrete technical requirement. Taking on WordPress maintenance only to avoid a hosted-platform subscription is a weak reason. The WooCommerce versus Shopify comparison goes deeper.

Squarespace: for content that helps people buy

Squarespace suits a product business that actively composes a website around stories, guides, and shopping. Its current Design Intelligence tools include AI-assisted site creation, followed by editor refinement.

The useful mechanism for selling is its product block: a catalog item can appear in another page or blog post, and product-editor updates flow to blocks containing it. That connects an educational article to an actual buying path while keeping product data in the catalog.

Choose it when writing that content and arranging the pages is how you want to spend your time. Include subscription, processing, and the relevant plan transaction fees in the cost; physical commerce and digital memberships have different fee categories. Our Squarespace e-commerce review covers that fit.

Big Cartel: for a deliberately compact creative shop

Big Cartel earns its place when an artist, maker, or small brand needs a focused shop and can work within defined catalog limits. Its official plan table, checked on 16 October 2026, lists 5 products on Gold, 50 on Platinum, and 500 on Diamond. The corresponding image caps are 1, 5, and 25 per product. See Big Cartel’s plans and features.

Those caps make the decision concrete. A five-product free shop works for a narrow launch, but one image per product is a poor fit for work that needs front, back, detail, and scale photographs. You may need the next tier for the images before you need it for the products.

The store is built from templates, with deeper design controls on paid plans. Choose it when a compact shop is the right shape for the business, not only because the entry price is the lowest. If you’re already running into those caps, our Big Cartel alternatives cover where to go next.

Choose for the next change, not only for launch

Take a business selling 20 notebooks that later launches a desk collection. The change is ordinary: add the products, introduce the collection, shift the homepage emphasis, keep the dimensions accurate, and make sure the route to checkout still works.

In Setka you describe those page changes, check them in preview, and publish, and the version before the change stays saved if you want it back. In Shopify or Big Cartel you work within the theme or template you chose and its controls. In Squarespace you compose the content and the product blocks. In WooCommerce you work within your WordPress stack and call whoever owns the implementation for anything deeper.

A specialist requirement can outweigh all of this: a required payment provider, POS, fulfillment connection, or buying flow needs a supported route first. Once that’s settled, choose the way of working you’ll repeat every season. If you’re ready to hand the storefront to the platform, create your Setka store with your real range and brand direction.