Keep WooCommerce if your WordPress site already brings people in, teaches them, and sends them to your products, and you have someone to maintain it. Move to Shopify if you want the platform to host the store and you’re happy to run its theme and apps. If neither appeals because the real burden is building and changing the store itself, look at Setka, our product, which builds the store inside its own commerce platform. We explain where it fits below.

If you are leaving WooCommerce rather than choosing between these two, start with WooCommerce alternatives. If BigCommerce is on your list, see BigCommerce vs. WooCommerce.

“I know WordPress” is a head start, not a reason. The reason to keep it is that its articles, navigation, and product explanations still earn their place. Years of effort in a site that now gets in the way is no reason to keep it.

What each choice leaves with you

WooCommerce is an open-source commerce platform for WordPress. You control the site, code, and data, and choose from themes and extensions. That makes it the natural way to add a catalog to a WordPress site that already works.

The host is part of that choice. You can run the installation yourself, pay for managed hosting, or pay a partner to look after it. For any managed option, ask who handles updates, backups, recovery, and plugin conflicts. A “managed” label rarely covers all four.

Shopify’s Online Store puts hosting inside the commerce platform. You choose a theme and configure it, and apps or a developer extend it where you need more. Ordinary changes fit the theme editor. The question is where your requirements cross from a setting into an app or custom work.

Your decisionWooCommerceShopify Online Store
Keep the existing WordPress siteBuild commerce into itDecide which content moves to Shopify and which stays outside
Who hosts the storeThe host and management service you chooseShopify
Shape the shopping experienceWordPress theme, WooCommerce settings, and extensionsShopify theme, editor settings, and apps or custom work
Keep additions workingWhoever maintains your theme and plugin combinationWhoever supports your apps and theme customizations
Approve the resultYou check facts, policies, and the purchase pathYou check facts, policies, and the purchase path

Neither “open source” nor “hosted” settles the workload. WooCommerce lets you choose more of the arrangement, and so leaves more of it with you. Shopify takes hosting off the list. With either, you still make the commercial decisions and check what customers see.

Keep the content that earns its place

List what in the WordPress site is still useful: articles that bring relevant visitors, tutorials your newsletter links to, material guides customers ask about, and the editor your team knows. Separate them from pages you would happily retire.

When that content and the catalog belong together, WooCommerce is the strong choice. A tutorial explains a technique, points to the right supplies, and stays in the publishing system you already use. The advantage is the working link between articles and products, not familiarity with WordPress.

Shopify has a built-in blog, so moving doesn’t mean giving up editorial content. But having a blog is not the same as having your blog: the articles, media, page layouts, and publishing habits you depend on still have to come across.

There is a middle path. Shopify’s Buy Buttons for external websites and blogs let you keep the WordPress content and manage the products behind the buttons in Shopify. It fits when you want Shopify’s commerce without moving the publication. WordPress stays yours to maintain, and you still check the route from article to purchase.

Don’t frame this as “which platform is better for SEO?” Decide first which URLs and article-to-product links must survive, then check how each setup keeps them. Neither platform brings visitors by itself.

The next product launch on each

Take a hypothetical maker with a WordPress embroidery blog who adds 18 physical kits. The articles teach stitches and explain fabric choices. Launch needs product descriptions, photos of finished work, kit contents, delivery terms, and a clear route to buy.

A month later, the maker adds a beginner kit. The newsletter promises a first project with clear instructions, so its page has to say what’s in the box, what equipment the buyer must supply, and what skill it assumes. A gift buyer may be an experienced embroiderer; someone buying for themselves may be new. The page serves both without assuming expertise from intent.

Then the featured kit changes again, to a seasonal project, and old newsletter links need to land somewhere useful.

On WooCommerce, the kit’s contents, price, and stock live in the product record, and the beginner guidance lives wherever your theme and page builder let you put it. If the current theme can’t place guidance next to the product, you add an extension or pay for a custom template, and that addition joins the list of things someone keeps compatible through WordPress and plugin updates. Old newsletter links keep working as long as you don’t move the pages.

On Shopify, the product record works the same way and Shopify hosts it. Whether the beginner guidance fits next to the product depends on the theme’s sections. A layout the theme doesn’t offer means an app or theme code, and that customization now has to survive theme updates. If the blog moves from WordPress, the old URLs need redirects in Shopify.

On both, the recurring work is the same: turning what you know about the kit into a page, rearranging it for the next launch, and checking the links. Most of it is presentation, not commerce. If the first launch stays mostly within tools you already know, keeping WordPress has a real advantage. If every launch turns into coordination with a developer you’d rather not call, Shopify takes away the hosting, not necessarily that dependency.

What each one costs

WooCommerce describes its platform as having no monthly platform fee (checked on 5 October 2026). That doesn’t make the store free. You pay for hosting, any paid theme, the extensions you need and their renewals, and whoever maintains it all.

Shopify’s pricing page, checked in the US on 16 October 2026, showed Basic at $39 a month billed monthly. If you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments, Shopify adds a third-party transaction fee of 2% on Basic, lower on higher plans, on top of the provider’s own processing charges. Add any paid theme and app subscriptions. Our Shopify pricing guide adds up a first year.

CostWooCommerceShopify
Base serviceHosting and any managed serviceShopify subscription
Existing publicationAlready in the siteRetained WordPress costs if it stays
PresentationPaid theme, builder, or implementation workPaid theme or implementation work
Added featuresExtension licenses and renewalsApp charges and usage limits
PaymentsYour provider’s processing chargesProcessing, plus the third-party fee if you don’t use Shopify Payments
Ongoing workMaintenance, recovery, and future changesTheme and app support, and future changes

For a small craft catalog, the license or subscription is rarely the largest line. Paid help for the next layout change usually is, on either side.

Before comparing totals, list the payment methods, selling countries, carriers, pickup options, tax handling, and accounting connections the business needs, and get each one confirmed for your country. “There is a plugin” or “there is an app” starts that check; it doesn’t finish it.

What switching involves

Owning the site and data is a reason to pick WooCommerce, but it doesn’t mean every plugin’s data or custom layout moves intact. A hosted platform doesn’t trap you either. What matters is the specific data and pages involved. Before retiring anything, list what must survive:

  • products, images, options, identifiers, prices, and stock;
  • customer and order records you need to keep accessing;
  • articles, media, useful page layouts, and links from content to products;
  • existing URLs, their new destinations, and redirects;
  • payment, delivery, tax, email, and other connected services.

Ask for the migration to be shown on a sample, and check that counts and meaning match, not just that a file imports. The e-commerce migration checklist goes through each item.

When the store itself is what you want to hand over

If WordPress is still a valuable publication, keep it: WooCommerce, or Shopify Buy Buttons for hosted checkout. Setka fits when you are choosing a new store and the work you want gone is building and changing its presentation.

Give Setka your brand direction, customer context, and catalog, and it builds the store inside its e-commerce platform: homepage, category pages, product pages, navigation, and cart, filled with your product facts and photos. For the beginner kit, you add its contents, equipment list, and description to the product, and the product page presents them. To feature it, open the homepage and describe the change, for example the beginner kit first with a line for people new to embroidery, then preview the result before publishing. Edit exact wording directly. There is no theme to update and no app to keep compatible, because Setka maintains the storefront and checkout as one platform. Every change creates a storefront-wide version, so the launch layout stays saved when the seasonal kit replaces it.

You still supply accurate facts and real photos, set policies, configure shipping and payments through your own Stripe account, and approve what goes live. For a new store, Setka usually costs much less than either route once the theme, extensions or apps, and the developer time to adapt them are counted, because the store is built into the platform. Setka’s price doesn’t rise with your sales volume; Stripe’s processing fees still apply.

Setka has a built-in blog and CMS. Embedding catalog products in a blog post is coming soon, and redirects from old URLs are not available yet. If you already sell on WooCommerce, we migrate your store data for you. If moving your WordPress archive, keeping a particular publishing workflow, or a specialist connection decides the choice, tell us at contact@getsetka.com before you move: requests go straight to the people building Setka.

Our view: if the WordPress site still earns its keep and you’re prepared to maintain it, keep it and add WooCommerce, or Shopify Buy Buttons if you want hosted checkout. If you are moving the store anyway and want to run a theme and apps yourself, choose Shopify. If you want to decide what the store says and hand over building it, brief a Setka store around the same kits and the next launch, and see current pricing.