Choose Medusa when your team wants ready commerce modules and a framework for building custom behavior on top of them, with agents doing part of the work. Choose Saleor when you want a GraphQL API at the center of a store composed from separate services, with webhooks that let those services extend its default flows. Both are open source, both sell a managed cloud, and both assume you have engineers who will own the result after launch.

That last point matters more than the architecture. If what you actually need is a distinctive store for an ordinary product catalog, you may not need a custom stack at all. Setka is our product, and it builds that store inside the platform that runs its commerce, with no codebase for you to maintain. We cover when that is the better purchase at the end.

The difference at a glance

Both engines have an admin, both are open source, and both can sit behind a storefront you choose. They differ in where your team puts the behavior that is specific to your business.

Part of the decisionMedusaSaleor
Where custom work livesIn its framework, built on commerce modulesIn external services connected through the GraphQL API and webhooks
Merchant administrationCustomizable adminDashboard with UI extension points
Commerce coverage it advertisesBundles, sales channels, multi-warehouse inventory, multiple currencies and regional tax, promotions with B2B pricingProduct, order, and translation management in the dashboard; dynamic product models
Managed offerMedusa Cloud, plus agent toolingSaleor Commerce Cloud and composable SaaS
StorefrontA frontend your team builds, by hand or with agentsPaper storefront, or a frontend you choose

Sources: Medusa and Saleor, as published on 16 October 2026.

Medusa: modules and a framework for agents

Medusa presents itself as an open-source platform to “build, customize, and operate your business with agents.” Its modules cover product management with bundles, multiple sales channels, inventory across warehouses, multiple currencies with local tax rules, and a promotion engine that includes B2B pricing. The admin is customizable, and the framework is described as guardrails for agents building customizations.

Medusa Cloud deploys from GitHub and adds agent tooling: an MCP server, a CLI, skills, and preview environments. Medusa says Cloud charges for infrastructure with no extra license fee or GMV charge.

This suits a team whose project needs business logic a theme can’t express: an unusual ordering process, a connection to a fulfillment or ERP system, or an admin screen shaped around how staff actually work. The modules give that team a working commerce base, so it builds only the parts that are specific to the business.

Agents change how fast that code gets written, not who answers for it. Generated customizations still need review against your business rules, and the application needs an owner after the first deployment. Put the value of agent tooling into the project estimate, and don’t let it quietly remove maintenance from the scope.

Saleor: a GraphQL API you extend from outside

Saleor describes itself as open-source, headless, and composable. A GraphQL API sits at the center, with more than 160 webhooks to keep other systems in sync. Synchronous webhooks let an external service extend Saleor’s default flows. The dashboard handles product information, orders, and translations, and accepts your own UI at more than 45 extension points. A CLI keeps the store’s configuration in your repository.

This suits a team that wants each system to do one job and connect through a defined API: a separate content system, search, or ERP, each owned deliberately. That freedom has a cost. Your team decides which system owns each piece of data and how changes move between them, and it maintains those connections.

Saleor is candid about who it is for. Its homepage says it is “not for everyone” and, to anyone who dislikes working with engineers, “we’re not your crew. Saleor is built for builders.”

The Paper storefront means “Saleor has no storefront” is no longer a fair objection. The real question is whether Paper, or another frontend, is one your team wants to own.

Either engine beats an improvised checkout

Teams often reach this comparison after outgrowing a plugin setup, and some are tempted to replace it with a CMS, a few product tables, and a payment integration. That skips the hard part. Commerce is the state around each transaction: what was ordered, whether it is paid, what can ship, and what a refund or change does to the record. Medusa and Saleor already model that state. A general-purpose app has to rebuild it. If you’re weighing that route, our guide to building a custom store with Replit, Base44, or Bolt covers it.

Before you compare the engines, sort your requirements into three groups: ordinary commerce, transaction behavior specific to your business, and presentation. A distinctive product page is presentation, not a reason for a custom backend. A real operating rule, such as negotiated prices or approval before an order ships, belongs in the second group. One documented way to build that rule can decide between the engines. A checklist of generic features can’t.

Budget for the team, not the license

Both clouds reduce the infrastructure your team runs. Neither runs the whole store. Keep three layers separate: the commerce service, the frontend, and the integrations between commerce and your other systems. A hosted backend doesn’t maintain your custom frontend, and someone still has to understand it.

The full budget is the managed service or hosting, the frontend, the integrations, the custom behavior, review, deployment, and ongoing support. Open-source code removes a license fee. The largest line in either budget is the team. A useful rule: if nobody will own the frontend and integrations after launch, neither engine is the right purchase yet.

Choose the proposal that names who owns each layer and shows an architecture that fits your requirements. Don’t choose on a claim that one engine scales better or ships in fewer weeks in every project.

When we’d choose Setka instead

We recommend Setka when the job is to build and keep changing a product store, not to commission an application.

The difference is who owns the implementation. Medusa and Saleor give your team a foundation to build on. Setka builds the store from your brief and catalog inside the platform that runs checkout, payments through your Stripe account, orders, and inventory. You describe a change on a page, edit exact wording, preview, and publish. Every change saves a version of the whole store, and you can branch from an earlier version or go back to it. There is no theme or generated codebase for anyone to maintain.

Faster code generation and removing implementation work are different benefits. If custom commerce logic is the point of the project, keep the engine comparison at the center. If the supposed custom requirement is mostly a brand-specific homepage, clearer categories, and better product pages, Setka is the more direct purchase, and it usually costs far less than a team building and maintaining a headless store. See current pricing.

Some requirements that justify these engines are ones Setka doesn’t cover yet. Each Setka store uses one currency, and B2B quoting, ERP connections, and customer accounts aren’t available yet. If one of them decides your launch, write to contact@getsetka.com and we’ll tell you yes, no, or not yet: requests go straight to the people building Setka.

If your team is building custom commerce, choose Medusa for the module-and-framework route and Saleor for the API-and-webhook route. If you want to direct the store yourself, see how Setka builds it.